How Westminster Works . . . and Why It Doesn't

Product Information

Ian Dunt walks the reader through, issue by issue, place by place, step by step, in an informative, engaging way that is genuinely hard to find in political works. Chancellors of the Exchequer normally turnover less than other Ministers, though there were five from 2020 to 2022 as PMs also turned over unusually fast. This has led to what Dunt describes as an “irrational,” unfair tax structure which facilitates tax avoidance, as the IFS has pointed out. Dunt stresses how exhausting and time-consuming is the work of MPs, their difficulties in achieving work-life balance.

Photograph: Scott E Barbour/Getty Images View image in fullscreen Woeful Westminster … Big Ben and the Houses of Parliament. A much-used word, karma is loosely understood as a system of checks and balances in our lives, of good actions and bad deeds, of good thoughts and bad intentions.Ian Dunt, though, thinks this is unfair, since Grayling is actually “a completely standard example of the quality of the ministerial class in Britain”. In the absolutely packed Act II, the dark fantasy resumes and the Sandman expands into the French Revolution, ancient Rome, 19th-century San Francisco, eighth-century Baghdad, and beyond. Above all, Dunt concludes, we need to fix “our own approach to politics which has led us to where we are now” and insist on “scrutiny, knowledge, restraint of power and full exchange of ideas” (pp. Turnover has increased, faster than in the many countries where reshuffles require coalition agreement.

Similarly useful would be the creation of a “parliamentary private office” and/or backbench department staffed with civil servants similar to the Congressional Budget Office in the US. This combined with a slow “drip-feed” of crossbench experts has ensured that no party has since held overall control, despite Boris Johnson’s best efforts. Deconstructing the processes and culture of the badly broken British political system in clear and accessible prose, the author of How to Be a Liberal reveals how we have got to this low point and how to start dragging Westminster out of the mire.There she is given the chance to undo her regrets and try out each of the other lives she might have lived. It is easy to stir up righteous anger, but Dunt does something far more useful in performing a detailed analysis of why none of this nonsense was stopped before it got started.

The House of Commons should control its own timetable, with a Business of the House Committee to agree a fortnightly agenda and put it to a free vote. The only place where it can and does receive good scrutiny and revisions for its legislation is in the House of Lords, but that can only recommend and slow down or delay the legislation, not to block it entirely.Let’s hope that by the next election, Ian’s prescription will be so wildly popular that Keir Starmer feels obliged to introduce proportional representation, professionalise the civil service, reform parliamentary procedures and all the other excellent points in the solutions chapter. Everything from our electoral system to our way of governing and debating and voting – it’s all set up to be a fight. Cleverly, the author approaches the political system layer by layer, starting with how citizens vote for candidates to be selected and how they vote them into Westminster once they have been selected.

Originally designed to pass uncontroversial technical changes, the technique has increasingly been exploited to get highly controversial matters through parliament. Best-selling author Mark Manson brings his signature no-nonsense wisdom back to the subject he started his career covering: relationships. An unfortunate absence from the book is any discussion of the constitutional role of the legal system. A Commission should direct tax policy, and spending policy should increase its focus on long-term growth. He sought no expert advice and ignored it when it was offered in response to a Ministry “consultation” on the issue, preferring to listen to costly, less expert, private sector consultants.I highly recommend everyone in the UK reads this, to understand what is happening in government on the mechanical level. I follow politics avidly, including a range of authoritative figures in the field, and I get my news from a wide range of sources across the political divide.